Ivory Li
Department of Psychology
The Ohio State University
Title: Accounting for Item Response Process and Response Styles Using the Unfolding Item Response Tree (UIRTree) Model
Abstract: Many researchers have found that unfolding models may better represent how respondents answer Liker-type items and response styles (RSs) often have moderate to strong presence in responses to such items. However, the two research lines have been growing largely in parallel. The present study proposed an unfolding item response tree (UIRTree) model that can account for unfolding response process and RSs simultaneously. An empirical illustration showed that the UIRTree model could fit a personality dataset well and produced more reasonable parameter estimates. Strong presence of the extreme response style (ERS) was also revealed by the UIRTree model. We further conducted a Monte Carlo simulation study to examine the performance of the UIRTree model compared to three other models for Likert-scale responses: the Samejima’s graded response model, the generalized graded unfolding model, and the dominance item response tree (DIRTree) model. Results showed that when data followed unfolding response process and contained the ERS, the AIC was able to select the UIRTree model, while BIC was biased towards the DIRTree model in many conditions. In addition, model parameters in the UIRTree model could be accurately recovered under realistic conditions, and wrongly assuming the item response process or ignoring RSs was detrimental to the estimation of key parameters. In general, the UIRTree model is expected to help in better understanding of responses to Liker-type items theoretically and contribute to better scale development practically. Future studies on multi-trait UIRTree models and UIRTree models accounting for different types of RSs are expected.
Discussant: Diana Zhu